Letter to the Editor: Mandatory Insurance is a Tax

By Robert Perino; Owasso

A couple of weeks ago President Obama made a statement in answer to a question he was asked. The question was something like, "Don't you think that making health care mandatory is like another tax on the people?" His answer was, "No, you have to buy car insurance and that's not considered an extra tax." No one challenged this statement. It is a false and misleading statement. First of all, auto insurance is regulated by the states, not the federal government. Does Obama want the states to handle health insurance? Probably not. Second, No state requires you to buy car insurance.

They require you to buy liability insurance to cover the other person if you have an accident in your vehicle. The state does not care if you have insurance on your car or the people in it. Third, liability insurance costs, on average, about $400 a year per vehicle. Mandatory health insurance for every person in your household will cost the average family in excess of $7,000 a year by Sen. Max Baucus's own figures, and that after a government rebate that won't start until 2013 at the earliest. How many people do you know that can afford to spend another $7,000 a year. Most of the families I know are having trouble paying the bills they have now. The question that should be asked by the media is not how much is mandatory health care going to cost the federal government, but how is the average family going to be able to pay the extra cost?

This letter was published exclusively online.

The Tulsa World publishes as many letters as possible within its standards and space limitations. The newspaper receives many more letters than it can publish. To help accommodate that surplus some letters are published online only. Letters that can't be edited below the 250-word limit on printed letters or that are written by an author who has published a letter in the past 30 days are often used online only. The newspaper also emphasizes local topics in printed letters. Letters addressing national or international events are often used online.

...

Read more...

Get Car Insurance Quote




Tulsa Car insurance - News


Vote for Jim Mautino Nov. 10
Most states, including Oklahoma, require motorists to buy car insurance. First, this is a state, not federal law. Secondly, driving is a privilege,

Q&A with Bill Cassetty: How does requiring insurance change Oklahoma home ...
Q&A with Bill Cassetty: How does requiring insurance change Oklahoma home A: No, there will still be some who will get their permit and then drop their insurance, similar to what happens with car tags. and more »

Ruined Property Tab Hits Millions
Sallisaw School Superintendent Ron Wyrick said he doesn't have a damage amount as insurance adjusters from the Brown Hiller Clark Insurance firm in Sallisaw and more »

New State Laws Go Into Effect
The bill requires the state to explore the purchase of a $20 million insurance policy by May 1, 2011, to create an indemnity fund for non-economic damages and more »

Best new-car buys begin online
OT, Tulsa. A tightening credit market, the need for automakers to move metal, and sizable government and automaker incentives are making it easier for